More than a million benefits sanctions imposed on disabled people since 2010
The DWP was just savaged in a ‘dossier of disgrace’
AUDIO –
https://spkt.io/a/99193
The Department for Work and Pensions (DWP) has been slammed in a report called ‘A Dossier of Disgrace’. The document shows a catalogue of errors. And one leading professional has accused the DWP of an “ideological standpoint” that “demonises” people.
The DWP: up to its neck in controversy. Again.
The National Union of British Sign Language Interpreters (NUBSLI) has released a report [pdf] into the state of play for British Sign Language (BSL) interpreters and deaf people in the UK. It follows reforms to the profession which have seen strikes, a company liquidated and deaf people struggling to get their communication needs met.
NUBSLI is unequivocal in where the blame lies for these failings: the government, and more specifically, the DWP.
Private companies in public bodies
In 2014, the government began [pdf, p4] introducing a national framework agreement around the provision of language services in public sector organisations. Essentially, the government introduced [pdf, p4] a competitive marketplace for interpreters into public bodies. The framework includes BSL interpreters in its remit. Its outline states:
As the main supply route for all public sector customers… our agreement ensures that they have access to quality interpreters… in an efficient and cost effective way.
The framework lists all the government approved companies that public sector bodies can use. Some agencies use self-employed interpreters. But NUBSLI believes that the framework has led to chaos in the interpreter profession, and for deaf people.
The report states [pdf, p4] that:
The whole concept of frameworks is that they can provide cost savings. By buying in bulk, it is expected that savings can be made… This model doesn’t work for services provided by professionals, whose overheads do not diminish.
NUBSLI has various concerns about the framework agreement. These include [pdf, p4] agency interpreter’s pay, and the “lack of accountability” if deaf people want to complain about a service.
This is where the DWP comes in. Because in 2017, it released a report on the state of the UK’s BSL interpreter profession. And NUBSLI claims [pdf, p9] the report was “not fit for purpose”.
A “marketplace review”
It says [pdf, p6-7] the DWP report, a “marketplace review”, did highlight the lack of BSL interpreters in the UK and also that deaf people’s needs were not being met. But overall, NUBSLI says [pdf, p3] the report ignored two crucial points:
- “The liquidation of a large spoken language agency… who cited frameworks as one reason for their liquidation”.
- “The boycott of another agency… by interpreters in response to a large reduction in fees to unsustainable levels”.
Both these points are examples of the concerns NUBSLI has over the framework agreement. But the DWP failed to highlight them, even though NUBSLI was on the steering group for the report [pdf, p6].
So, where has this left BSL interpreters and deaf people? NUBSLI still have overarching concerns [pdf, p10]:
The situation is so bad that even a UN report in September 2017 highlighted [pdf, p3]the lack of BSL interpreters. But this is not the end of the story for deaf people. Because while controversy still surrounds the framework agreement, the DWP is busy eroding deaf people’s communication support even further.
Access to work
As NUBSLI’s report also highlights, the DWP has restricted a policy called Access to Work. It’s a scheme where the DWP gives a grant to an employee for changes or support they need to carry out their job. This is on top of any reasonable adjustments an employer should make under the Equality Act 2010.
But since 2015, Access to Work has been capped. As The Canary previously reported, a deaf person affected by the cap has taken the DWP to court over it, with the result still pending. And as NUBSLI outlines [pdf, p8] in its report, changes to the scheme have:
led to people losing much needed support and placed jobs at risk.
Overall, NUBSLI notes that the framework agreement, combined with Access to Work, could present serious issues. It says [pdf, p8]:
The [framework agreement] will instigate its own cap on the hourly amount for any contract. Any agency administering the [Access to Work] budget for a Deaf person will use this amount to cut the rates of pay for an interpreter… The fees offered to a [BSL] interpreter will be below market rates… resulting in even fewer interpreters being available to work within [Access to Work] settings…
And it notes [pdf, p8]:
The DWP is attempting to control the market by using a framework that does not follow the market rates interpreters charge.
“Demonising” people
NUBSLI branch secretary Samantha Riddle told The Canary:
These findings are no surprise to anyone familiar with the DWP. Specifically, their practice of ignoring any evidence which doesn’t fit with their ideological standpoint; one of demonising service providers and users under the guise of austerity. They have repeatedly ignored warnings against the use of framework agreements for BSL/English interpreting provision; as seen in their marketplace review… Which failed to include the liquidation of Pearl Linguistics and the boycott of Language Line Solutions.Framework agreements started a race to the bottom. The rights of… deaf people and service providers are ignored in favour of the customer’s bottom line and the agency’s profit margin. Appointments are left unfulfilled, or unqualified/inexperienced interpreters are being used… This model is unstable… We need the DWP to admit this sooner rather than later. Because ultimately it is deaf people who are suffering.
As NUBSLI’s report says, there is a catalogue of failures surrounding interpreters and deaf people’s right to them. It’s a damning indictment of a worsening situation, one that encapsulates what happens when a private ‘marketplace’ gets involved in public services. And as always, it’s those who can least afford to be penalised, who ultimately suffer.
The Canary contacted the DWP for comment but had received none at the time of publication.
Get Involved!
– If you are a deaf person or BSL interpreter with concerns contact NUBSLI at communications@nubsli.com
– Follow NUBSLI on Twitter.
– Sign the petition to stop Access to Work changes.
Featured image via UK government – Wikimedia and NUBSLI – screengrab
Become a Canary member to support fearless independent journalism
source: https://www.thecanary.co/uk/analysis/2018/07/28/the-dwp-was-just-savaged-in-a-dossier-of-disgrace/
Archive:
SCANDALOUS! “The DWP just revealed the eye-watering millions it paid out to private companies” [don’t forget the highly questionable “Prospects Workfair”] – JULY 26TH, 2018 + archive
The DWP just revealed the eye-watering millions it paid out to private companies JULY 26TH, 2018 STEVE TOPPLE TRENDING, UK https://spkt.io/a/98811On Thursday 26 July, the Department for Work and Pensions (DWP) revealed the amount it paid out in June to private contractors. It’s … Continue reading
The DWP sneaked out a damning admission just before parliament closed for the summer – The Canary 26 July 2018 + archive
JULY 25TH, 2018 STEVE TOPPLE ANALYSIS, UK The Department for Work and Pensions (DWP) released some damning information about benefit sanctions; conveniently just as parliament was closing for its summer holidays. The DWP: sanctions and mental health On Tuesday 24 July, minister of … Continue reading
DWP WRONG AGAIN: “The #DWP just admitted a court case it lost will affect thousands of people” AUDIO + ATOS + SANCTIONS DEATHS + archive
The DWP just admitted a court case it lost will affect thousands of people JULY 11TH, 2018 STEVE TOPPLE ANALYSIS, UK https://spkt.io/a/95341 The Department for Work and Pensions (DWP) just admitted that a court case it lost means it may have to pay … Continue reading
The Carol Woods Coverup: the house theft, the ID frauds, Mike Todd’s murder, DWP frauds + more 30 May 2018 + archive
Why will noone dare sort this massive corruption out? The “Preface” directly below, followed by the most recent updates from 30 – 26 May 18 from Carol Woods. The posts detail the serious crime occurring to Carol, and connected to … Continue reading
SHOCKING: “Hundreds losing disability benefits in Personal Independence Payments shake-up” + The DWP has been caught trying to ‘coerce’ GPs into saying their patients are fit-for-work – 29 May 2018
“Hundreds losing disability benefits in Personal Independence Payments shake-up” – Echo Hundreds losing disability benefits in Personal Independence Payments shake-up Will Frampton WFrampton_Echo HUNDREDS of disabled people in Dorset lost their benefits when they were reassessed for a new government … Continue reading
DISGRACEFUL: “The DWP left one man so ‘destitute’ that the police had to step in to help him” – The Canary
The DWP left one man so ‘destitute’ that the police had to step in to help him MAY 18TH, 2018 STEVE TOPPLE TRENDING, UK TRENDING The Department for Work and Pensions (DWP) reportedly left one man so “destitute” that police were called out … Continue reading
Dying mum told by DWP to prove for third time that her cancer is terminal – MetroUK
Bradley JollyWednesday 4 Apr 2018 3:41 pm MORE: Most people are now winning their appeals against disability benefit decisions MORE: Every PIP claim reassessed: Here’s what you need to know source: http://metro.co.uk/2018/04/04/dying-mum-told-by-dwp-to-prove-for-third-time-that-her-cancer-is-terminal-7440437/?ito=amp-share-facebook-top?ito=cbshare see more: ‘Suicidal’ man with anorexia told … Continue reading
The DWP is in court again and it could ‘open the floodgates’ for countless disabled people – the Canary
The DWP is in court again and it could ‘open the floodgates’ for countless disabled people APRIL 30TH, 2018 STEVE TOPPLE ANALYSIS, UK Spread the word: Facebook Twitter ANALYSIS https://tpc.googlesyndication.com/safeframe/1-0-23/html/container.htmlTHE VIEWS EXPRESSED IN THIS PIECE ARE NOT INTENDED AS LEGAL ADVICE. The Department … Continue reading
OUTRAGEOUS: The DWP has been caught trying to ‘coerce’ GPs into saying their patients are fit-for-work – the Canary – PEOPLE ARE DIEING
The DWP has been caught trying to ‘coerce’ GPs into saying their patients are fit-for-work APRIL 27TH, 2018 STEVE TOPPLE ANALYSIS, DISCOVERY, HEALTH Campaigners and medical professionals have discovered the Department for Work and Pensions (DWP) is trying to “coerce” GPs into saying that their sick … Continue reading
The Carol Woods Coverup: Falsely arrested – DWP FRAUD LA2 found out, reported, reprisals offered, threaten eviction 28 March 2018 + archive
Some Background – why does Carol Woods suffer so much harassment still, since whistleblowing in 2001?: Carol Woods = “It is a highly complex matter which the police organise where they try to make me someone I am not. They … Continue reading
The Carol Woods Coverup: Falsely arrested – DWP FRAUD LA2 found out, reported, reprisals offered, threaten eviction 28 March 2018 + archive
Some Background – why does Carol Woods suffer so much harassment still, since whistleblowing in 2001?: Carol Woods = “It is a highly complex matter which the police organise where they try to make me someone I am not. They … Continue reading
DWP goes back to court to block future benefit appeals – 20 Feb. 2018
The DWP is using a bedroom tax case to challenge future welfare appeals By Natalie BloomerTuesday, 20 February 2018 10:15 AM 7 The government is back in court today in a second attempt to block a legal route used by many people … Continue reading
DWP’s contracted outfit ATOS hardly cut it – “Private Eye” no. 1460 + BENEFIT SANCTIONS + more
“Private Eye” – no. 1460 – 23/12/17 – 10/01/18 Monday, 19 September 2016 OUTRAGEOUS!! Diabetic man blames DWP benefit sanctions for leg amputation + “HOLD AN INQUIRY INTO BENEFIT SANCTIONS THAT KILLED MY BROTHER!” + MORE Diabetic man blames DWP … Continue reading
The Shocking Carol Woods Coverup: Thefts / DWP fraudsters exposed – 03 Dec. 17 + archive
Some Background Carol Wood’s situation: Carol Woods = “It is a highly complex matter which the police organise where they try to make me someone I am not. They have in fact tried to invent me as the reverse of myself … Continue reading
The Shocking Carol Woods Coverup: DWP Frauds: past and present, Public Monies used to Defraud, Mike Todd murder, + archive 25 Nov. 17
On 23 November 2017 at 14:31, Data Analysis wrote: This is for the record: I found the car KX66 driving about rural areas to confirm something he would claim was FACT when it would be FICTION. That seen by … Continue reading
Desperate disabled gran attempted suicide after brutal DWP cuts left her fearing she would lose her home 18 Nov 17 D. Mirror + MUST SEE LINKS
Originally posted on VICTIMS OF THE STATE:
Revealed: DWP’s secret, ‘financially devastating’ proposals for benefits appeals 0 By John Pring on April 21, 2016 Benefits and Poverty Listen The Department for Work and Pensions (DWP) has drawn up secret plans…
Revealed: DWP’s secret, ‘financially devastating’ proposals for benefits appeals 0 By John Pring on April 21, 2016 Benefits and Poverty Listen The Department for Work and Pensions (DWP) has drawn up secret plans…
OUTRAGEOUS!! Diabetic man blames DWP benefit sanctions for leg amputation + DAVID CLAPSON: “HOLD AN INQUIRY INTO BENEFIT SANCTIONS THAT KILLED MY BROTHER!”
OUTRAGEOUS!! Diabetic man blames DWP benefit sanctions for leg amputation + DAVID CLAPSON: “HOLD AN INQUIRY INTO BENEFIT SANCTIONS THAT KILLED MY BROTHER!” Posted on September 19, 2016 by butlincat above: Jeremy Corbyn Diabetic man blames DWP benefit sanctions for leg amputation17:55, … Continue reading
Posted in Uncategorized Leave a comment
UK: DWP AGAIN IN DISREPUTE OVER DUBIOUS AND SHOCKING LONGRUNNING CASE – 29 Sept. 17
You know it’s bad news for the DWP when a judge begins his ruling with ‘Oh dear. Oh dear. Oh dear.’ September 28th, 2017 Emily Apple UK It is very unusual for a judge to start the introduction [pdf, … Continue reading
OUTRAGEOUS! “Terminally ill woman found ‘fit for work’ by callous DWP needs your help”
Despite being diagnosed with terminal cancer, Claire was found ‘fit for work’ by the Department for Work and Pensions. Sue Jones On Mar 1, 2017 Last updated Mar 1, 2017 Claire Hardwicke. Photo: Tiffany Williams/JustGiving 4.6K Shares Share Tweet … Continue reading
